Guide to Procurement Audits: Putting Insights into Action
Guide to Procurement Audits: Putting Insights into Action
Procurement audits show what's working, what isn't, and where you can improve your processes for cost savings and efficiency gains. But conducting an accurate audit and turning its findings into actionable steps can be complex.
When approached strategically, audits don’t just highlight issues—they create accountability, clarify priorities, and uncover opportunities to improve both processes and outcomes.
This guide outlines the key elements of a procurement audit, explains how to conduct one, and shows how you can turn the results into an action plan that cuts costs and boosts efficiency.
Download the free guide: Spend Analysis Toolkit
What is a procurement audit?
A procurement audit is a thorough evaluation of how your business requisitions and purchases goods and services, covering the entire procurement process. Audit teams typically examine four key areas:
- Compliance: Ensures your policies meet industry standards, government regulations, data privacy and security requirements, and internal protocols across procurement procedures and vendor partnerships
- Efficiency: Identifies bottlenecks and redundancies in your procurement pipeline, reducing wasted resources and highlighting opportunities to improve spend control
- Vendor relationships: Examines contract terms, performance, invoices, signs of fraud, duplicate payments, discrepancies, and ethical practices
- Strategic alignment: Confirms whether your procurement function supports broader company goals; includes market benchmarking to inform pricing and adapting to industry changes
Ultimately, an audit is a strategic mechanism for enforcing accountability and driving continuous improvement. It also reflects procurement's changing role. As highlighted by The Procurist, “Procurement’s role has evolved. It’s no longer just about managing costs and suppliers. Teams are expected to support sustainability, ensure resilience, assess risk, and contribute to growth.”
By leveraging procurement audits, your procurement department can systematically evaluate key areas and responsibilities to move beyond transactional tasks to a more holistic, strategic function.
Types of procurement audits and their benefits
One primary reason for a procurement audit is to eliminate cost leakage. According to Inverto’s 2025 CPO Survey, "Savings remain the top Procurement KPI (cost avoidance for 48%, recurring savings for 45%)." But audits address more than just cost—they also evaluate compliance, efficiency, and contractual performance, with each audit type serving a distinct purpose:
- Performance and contract audit: Reviews contract terms to ensure external stakeholders meet expectations, deliverables, and pricing. This prevents contract breaches, overpayments, and performance gaps.
- Financial audit: Evaluates how your organization spent each dollar and whether the appropriate approvals were in place. This helps find cost-saving opportunities and mitigate overspending.
- Supplier audit: Analyzes provider health, including financial stability, ethical standards, compliance, brand reputation, and qualifications. These audits assess vendor risk and inform long-term goals for supplier selection.
- Compliance audit: Inspects adherence to procurement laws, regulations, and ethics. Auditing for compliance ensures you maintain proper documentation and reduces exposure to legal or regulatory challenges.
- Risk management audit: Examines risks for the entire procurement cycle (strategic, financial, and operational). A risk management audit supports agile planning and long-term resilience.
Pro tip: Use the free Financial Audit Preparation Checklist to perform in-depth, accurate evaluations. If you’re working on a supplier audit, use the Vendor Risk Management Checklist as a starter framework to improve vendor selection.
4 audit planning best practices
Effective procurement audit processes are transparent and actionable. Use the following procurement practices to perform an accurate and useful audit.
1. Define your audit objective and scope
Start each audit with a clear goal. Without a defined objective, you can’t identify key metrics or determine which areas to examine. Establishing a vision and a timeframe ensures you select the appropriate audit type and scope for meaningful insights.
Common procurement management goals audits help address include:
- Improving compliance with internal policies and governing bodies
- Enhancing cost efficiency to reduce costs and limit waste
- Evaluating supplier performance to make sure vendors meet agreed-upon standards
- Identifying process improvement opportunities to eliminate bottlenecks and optimize operations
Pro tip: Plan your audit frequency based on risk and severity level. For example, you can conduct a supplier audit annually to assess risks and run financial audits quarterly in fast-moving operations.
2. Collect relevant documentation
Once you've identified the focus of your audit, gather all relevant documentation, logs, and workflow records to conduct a thorough review.
For example, if your procurement team is auditing vendor performance, you'll want to collect:
- Procurement contracts
- Purchase orders
- Supplier evaluations
- Vendor communication records
- Delivery information
- Contract compliance documents
Regardless of audit type, automating documentation and tracking saves time and allows you to capture precise, verifiable procurement data. Procurement software like Order.co supports this by providing detailed spend analysis, approval workflows, and centralized recordkeeping. By maintaining comprehensive procurement data as part of day-to-day operations, Order.co makes routine audits faster, more precise, and easier to execute.
Pro tip: For a financial audit, like an accounts payable audit, don’t rely on outdated paper-based systems. Use paperless solutions to reduce costs and speed up the process.
Spend Analysis Toolkit
Unlock savings, improve supplier relationships, and make smarter procurement decisions with clearer spend insights. Download the ebook to get started.
3. Audit the end-to-end procurement process
With your scope defined and your documentation in place, it's time to review the entire procurement lifecycle. Examine each step, including:
- Sourcing: Look at how your team sources new products to spot maverick spend and similar inefficiencies
- Vendor approval: Research whether new vendors went through the approval process to find consolidation opportunities and leverage bulk purchasing
- Invoice accuracy and compliance: Verify that vendor invoices are accurate and that suppliers are meeting their contractual terms to control spend
- Performance monitoring: Confirm vendors consistently provide quality products and timely deliveries to ensure your expectations are being met
- Documentation and legal compliance: Examine whether your team has maintained the required documentation for compliance and enforced legal requirements to avoid issues with regulators
- Risk assessment: Track how risks have evolved in the market and with your vendors for better long-term planning
4. Embed your learnings within a tool for a continuous system
As audit findings surface, incorporating and automating necessary realignments into your procurement process is essential to ensure long-term impact. The best way to do this is through a platform that helps you manage the entire procurement cycle.
With an all-in-one solution, you can manage vendor selection, maintain relationships, place and track orders, send and receive invoices, and create pre-approval parameters. These capabilities make it easy to establish an auditable procurement workflow so you can address issues in real time rather than after they escalate.
For example, Grasshopper Farms once purchased $70,000 in supplies from a vendor that later filed for bankruptcy. Because the company uses Order.co as its procurement solution, it was able to quickly identify the issue through the platform’s visibility features and recover the full amount.
How to draft clear, actionable audit reports
While auditing helps match expectations with reality, it’s only effective if you can communicate your findings and new trajectory clearly. Follow these steps to create a report that's relevant, specific, and actionable.
Build a summary and scope
Begin your report with a concise executive summary. State the purpose, objective, and the type of procurement management audit you conducted, along with its scope and timeframe.
Use this section as an opportunity to secure senior leadership buy-in. For example, if you performed a risk management audit, highlight potential costs from risks like a vulnerable supply chain and outline your current supplier consolidation efforts. This demonstrates to stakeholders why the findings matter, the cost of inaction, and the specific steps to mitigate risk and seize market opportunities.
After the summary, explain your methodology. Include the documentation, approval workflows, and other records you analyzed to reach your conclusions.
Explain your audit findings in detail and with evidence
Once you've established the context of the audit, share your findings with clear evidence. This section of the report should reflect an objective "state of procurement" and contain specific details about what you learned.
Make sure any claims you make are directly tied to data. For example, if you say the supply chain is unpredictable, specify the countries involved and their volatility. Then explain which vendors fall into these risk categories and why that matters. If senior management has a contrary view, you can refer back to this evidence to support your position.
Communicate the risks and impact
In this stage of audit communication, go beyond high-level observations by showing their implications for your company. Quantify potential effects, such as how a tariff hike could change sales or expenditures under different scenarios. If political or economic instability threatens a key supplier, outline how that could affect inventory levels or order fulfillment.
After laying out these scenarios, provide tailored, actionable solutions. Building an accurate, specific, and relevant report gives stakeholders the information they need to make informed decisions.
Spend Analysis Toolkit
Unlock savings, improve supplier relationships, and make smarter procurement decisions with clearer spend insights. Download the ebook to get started.
"*" indicates required fields
Remediation tips: Next steps after an audit
Without a clear growth plan, an audit is only a static report. The following steps can help you maximize your audit's ROI.
Offer measurable recommendations
Effective recommendations are specific, achievable, and tied to business goals. For example, if you want to cut procurement time by 50%, as EPIC4 did with the help of Order.co, begin by setting a defined goal and the steps to get there, such as vendor consolidation and stricter spend controls.
You can adapt the Lean Startup method to turn your procurement audit findings into actionable insights through a continuous improvement loop:
- Build: Create or improve procurement activities or policies
- Measure: Use regular audits to assess outcomes and track progress
- Learn: Distill insights and return to the build stage with the next iteration
You can also track post-audit procurement performance using common procurement metrics, including:
- Purchase order accuracy to identify errors that, when corrected, can reduce costs and improve vendor performance
- Compliance rate to measure adherence to internal and external policies
- Supplier lead time to monitor vendor reliability, help optimize inventory management, and inform risk mitigation strategies
- Purchase order cycle time to measure time across key purchasing processes, from order creation to fulfillment
- Spend under management to evaluate how much spend is under control
Include a next steps section
After presenting measurable recommendations, it's important to clarify your suggested corrective actions. While you've already highlighted what should change, you now need to outline who is responsible, when it should happen, and how progress will be tracked.
First, assign ownership of each change to a specific leader. Pair that responsibility with a defined scope of work and a timeline for review to create a feedback loop that reinforces audit goals and monitors progress.
With an all-in-one procurement solution, you can also create approval workflows for your vendors and products. This helps ensure that spend control and process improvements are implemented effectively after the audit.
How Order.co supports audit-readiness
Manual procurement audits can drain resources, especially when they rely on fragmented data, siloed systems, and time-consuming processes. With modern technology, audit readiness doesn't have to come at the expense of accuracy or efficiency.
The Order.co procurement platform maintains detailed purchasing and accounting information through automatic workflows, order and invoice management, and real-time spend reporting. Its features help you meet compliance requirements and produce clear and transparent audits—without the manual lift.
In addition to audit support, Order.co unifies the entire procurement process by letting you:
- Gain a holistic view of your procurement activities with a centralized dashboard
- Track where every dollar goes with comprehensive spend analysis
- Maintain audit visibility through approval workflow documentation
- Enforce procurement policies through effective internal controls
Schedule a demo today to see how Order.co can help you perform a successful procurement audit and take control over your process for more time and savings.
Get started
Schedule a demo to see how Order.co can simplify buying for your business
"*" indicates required fields
