Virtual Card vs. Physical Card: Weighing the Pros and Cons of a Virtual-First Strategy
Virtual Card vs. Physical Card: Weighing the Pros and Cons of a Virtual-First Strategy
As businesses move away from manual, paper-based processes, the debate over virtual cards vs. physical corporate cards has become a central focus for finance and operations leaders. The shift to digital payments has accelerated, pushing many organizations to consider a virtual-first approach to manage employee spending, online subscriptions, and vendor payments. But is eliminating plastic the right move for every company?
A virtual-first corporate card strategy promises greater security, granular control, and streamlined reconciliation. However, it also presents challenges for in-person transactions and vendor acceptance. This article provides a balanced, data-backed comparison to help you weigh the pros and cons and determine the best corporate card strategy for your growing business.
Download the free ebook: Choose the Right Procurement Technology With This Decision Matrix
What are virtual corporate cards?
Virtual corporate cards are unique, randomly generated 16-digit card numbers with a corresponding expiration date and CVV, created for specific payment purposes. Unlike physical cards, they exist only digitally and are typically used for online transactions, subscriptions, and payments to specific vendors. They can be single-use, expiring after one transaction, or multi-use for recurring payments, offering a flexible and secure way to manage company spending.
What are physical corporate cards?
Physical corporate cards are the traditional plastic credit or debit cards issued to employees for business-related expenses. These cards are tied to a company's line of credit or bank account and are primarily used for in-person purchases, such as travel and entertainment (T&E), client dinners, or office supplies. Each card is assigned to a specific employee, who is responsible for tracking receipts and submitting expense reports.
Choose the Right Procurement Technology With This Decision Matrix
Find 15 must-ask questions to narrow down your software search and make your research process MUCH easier.
Pros of a virtual-first corporate card strategy
A virtual-first strategy offers superior security, enhanced spend control, and streamlined operational efficiency. By leveraging digitally-generated card numbers for specific purposes, businesses can proactively prevent fraud, enforce spending policies automatically, and significantly reduce the administrative burden on finance teams.
Unmatched security and fraud prevention
One of the greatest benefits of virtual corporate cards is their robust security. Each virtual card can be locked to a specific vendor, spend limit, and timeframe. If a card number is compromised in a data breach, the potential for fraudulent activity is dramatically minimized because the card is restricted and cannot be used for unauthorized purchases elsewhere. Single-use cards take this a step further, becoming useless after one transaction.
This stands in stark contrast to physical cards. A lost, stolen, or skimmed physical card exposes the entire account to risk until it is reported and canceled, creating a significant security liability and potential for substantial financial loss.
Granular spend control and real-time visibility
Virtual cards give finance leaders unprecedented control over company spend. You can instantly issue a card for a specific purpose — like a new software subscription or a digital ad campaign — with a built-in budget and usage parameters. This proactive approach ensures employees stay within budget and adhere to company policy, eliminating maverick spend before it happens.
When integrated into a comprehensive platform, every transaction is tracked in real time, providing complete visibility into who is spending what, where, and when. This level of control is difficult to achieve with physical cards, which often rely on reactive expense reporting and manual oversight after the money has already been spent. A platform that enables centralized purchasing gives you the power to enforce policies from the start.
Simplified expense management and reconciliation
The reconciliation process for physical corporate cards is notoriously time-consuming, involving manual receipt collection, expense report submissions, and tedious data entry. Virtual cards can transform this workflow. Because each card is created for a specific purpose, transactions can be pre-coded with details like GL code, department, and project.
This level of automation streamlines the month-end close by eliminating manual data entry and guesswork. When transactions are automatically categorized at the point of sale, finance teams can reconcile accounts much faster. This is a core benefit of procurement automation, freeing up your team to focus on more strategic financial analysis.
Instant issuance and deactivation
Onboarding a new employee or starting a new project often requires immediate purchasing power. With physical cards, you face a delay of days or even weeks waiting for the card to be manufactured and mailed. Virtual cards, however, can be generated and issued instantly through a software platform. This agility allows teams to move quickly without being held up by administrative hurdles.
Similarly, when an employee leaves or a project concludes, their virtual cards can be deactivated with a single click, immediately cutting off access to company funds and eliminating any lingering risk.
Cons of a virtual-first corporate card strategy
The primary drawbacks of a virtual-first strategy are its limitations with in-person transactions and potential vendor acceptance issues. While ideal for online and subscription-based spending, a purely virtual approach can create friction for employees who need to make purchases in the physical world.
Challenges with in-person purchases
The most significant limitation of a virtual-only program is its incompatibility with traditional point-of-sale (POS) systems that require a physical card to swipe or insert. This makes them unsuitable for common business expenses like team lunches, in-store supply runs, or paying for gas during business travel.
While many virtual card providers offer integration with mobile wallets like Apple Pay or Google Pay, this isn't a perfect solution. Not all employees have compatible devices, and more importantly, not all merchants accept mobile payments. This gap can leave traveling employees in a difficult position and force them to pay out-of-pocket, defeating the purpose of a corporate card program.
Vendor acceptance and setup complexity
While most online merchants readily accept virtual cards, some smaller or more traditional vendors may be unfamiliar with or hesitant to process "card-not-present" transactions. Their systems may not be configured for manual entry, or their internal fraud prevention policies might flag such payments. This can lead to declined transactions and create payment friction that requires manual intervention from your finance team to resolve.
Reliance on digital infrastructure
Virtual cards are a product of the digital age and, as such, depend entirely on reliable internet access. To generate or access a virtual card number, an employee needs a connection. This can pose a problem for teams working in remote locations, traveling through areas with poor connectivity, or experiencing an internet outage at a critical moment. In these scenarios, a physical card provides a reliable backup that isn't dependent on digital infrastructure.
Potential for employee inconvenience
For employees who travel frequently, managing a virtual-first card program can feel more complex than carrying a single physical card. They may need to generate new cards for different expenses (e.g., one for the flight, one for the hotel, one for a rental car) and rely on mobile wallet functionality, which can be inconsistent. This can add a layer of administrative work and stress for the employee, potentially impacting their productivity on the road.
Choose the Right Procurement Technology With This Decision Matrix
Find 15 must-ask questions to narrow down your software search and make your research process MUCH easier.
"*" indicates required fields
When does a hybrid approach make the most sense?
A hybrid model, which combines the strategic use of both virtual and physical cards, is often the most practical solution for businesses with diverse spending needs. This approach allows a company to leverage the strengths of each card type while mitigating their respective weaknesses, creating a flexible and comprehensive spend management program.
By segmenting company spend, you can assign the right tool for the right job.
- Use virtual cards for: online software subscriptions, digital marketing campaigns, vendor payments, and one-off project expenses. This covers the bulk of predictable, non-T&E spend, giving you maximum security and control.
- Use physical cards for: employee travel, client entertainment, in-store purchases, and other T&E expenses where in-person payment is required.
This balanced approach provides the security and automation benefits of virtual cards for the majority of your spend while equipping traveling employees with the reliable, universally accepted payment method they need. It’s a pragmatic way to solve for the pros and cons of a virtual-first corporate card strategy.
How to implement a successful virtual-first program
A successful implementation requires more than just choosing a card provider; it demands a clear policy, the right technology platform, and effective employee training to ensure smooth adoption and compliance.
Develop a clear corporate card policy
Before issuing a single card, document a comprehensive policy that outlines the rules of engagement. This policy should clearly define when to use virtual vs. physical cards, establish spending limits by role and department, and detail the approval workflows for requesting new cards or budget increases. A well-defined policy removes ambiguity and empowers employees to spend confidently and correctly.
Choose a unified spend management platform
Standalone corporate card solutions only address a fraction of your company's spending. True control comes from a unified platform that integrates card management with your broader procurement process. A system that can manage virtual cards, purchase orders, and other payment methods provides a single source of truth for all company spend. This holistic view is critical for accurate forecasting, strategic sourcing, and identifying potential cash leaks.
Train your team effectively
Don't assume your team will intuitively understand how to use a new virtual card system. Conduct thorough training sessions that explain the benefits of the program (especially improved security) and provide step-by-step instructions for requesting, using, and managing virtual cards. Clear communication and accessible support resources are key to driving adoption and ensuring the program's success.
Beyond the card: Unifying spend for total control with Order.co
While a virtual-first card strategy is a powerful tool for managing a specific type of spend, it is ultimately only one piece of the puzzle. The most forward-thinking finance leaders understand that true spend efficiency and control come from unifying all purchasing and payments into a single, automated platform that addresses spend at its origin.
Order.co is not just a card provider; it is an AI-powered procurement and finance automation platform that centralizes the entire purchase-to-pay process. While virtual cards provide control at the point of payment, Order.co provides control at the point of purchase. Its guided marketplace ensures employees can only order pre-approved products from preferred vendors, preventing out-of-policy spend before a card is ever needed.
With features like Consolidated Billing, it eliminates the need for your AP team to chase down and reconcile hundreds of individual card transactions. Order.co pays your vendors upfront and sends you a perfectly-coded consolidated invoice containing purchases from all your vendors, reducing AP workload by up to 80%. This goes far beyond the benefits of a card program to fundamentally streamline your purchase order processing and financial operations.
A virtual card is a tool. A unified purchasing platform like Order.co is a complete strategy.
Ready to move beyond basic card management and gain total control over your business buying? Schedule a demo to see how Order.co can simplify purchasing, automate payments, and bring true order to your spend.
Get started
Schedule a demo to see how Order.co can simplify buying for your business.
"*" indicates required fields
