Managing vendor payments effectively is a constant challenge for growing businesses. As companies scale, decentralized purchasing often leads to a spike in maverick spend—unapproved purchases that happen outside of established procurement channels. Traditional corporate credit cards, often shared among team members, offer little visibility and even less control, making it nearly impossible to enforce budgets or prevent out-of-policy spending. This lack of oversight not only drains the budget but also creates security risks and complicates month-end reconciliation.

To solve this, finance and operations leaders are turning to more advanced payment tools: virtual cards and purchase cards. Both offer a significant upgrade in control compared to traditional methods. But they function differently and solve distinct business challenges. While purchase cards streamline low-value buys, virtual cards provide unparalleled, transaction-specific security and control, especially for online vendor payments.

This article compares virtual cards and purchase cards, explaining how each works to control vendor payments. We’ll cover how to set per-transaction limits, the pros and cons of a virtual-first strategy, and why the most effective approach combines the control of these cards with a centralized purchasing platform.

Download the free ebook: Choose the Right Procurement Technology With This Decision Matrix

What are virtual cards?

A virtual card is a unique, digitally generated 16-digit card number, complete with a CVV and expiration date, that is used for online transactions. Unlike a physical card, it exists only in a digital format and is created through a software platform. Each virtual card can be generated for a specific purpose, vendor, or even a single transaction, providing an exceptional layer of security and control.

Virtual cards are not directly linked to a primary company bank account or a physical credit card. Instead, they act as a secure proxy, protecting your core financial information from exposure. If a virtual card’s details are ever compromised in a data breach, it can be deleted instantly without affecting any other cards or your primary account. This makes virtual cards for vendor payments a powerful tool for reducing fraud and managing online subscriptions.

What are purchase cards (P-cards)?

A purchase card, or P-card, is a type of corporate charge card issued to specific employees to make authorized, business-related purchases. P-cards are designed to streamline the procurement of low-value goods and services by eliminating the need for a formal purchase order process for every small transaction. This empowers employees to buy necessary items quickly, from office supplies to software subscriptions, while adhering to company spending policies.

P-cards function like standard credit cards at the point of sale but come with built-in controls. Administrators can set monthly spending limits, restrict purchases to certain merchant category codes (MCCs), and block transactions at specific types of businesses (like bars or casinos). This gives companies a way to manage spending without the administrative burden of processing countless small invoices and reimbursement requests.

Ebook

Choose the Right Procurement Technology With This Decision Matrix

Find 15 must-ask questions to narrow down your software search and make your research process MUCH easier.

Download the ebook

Can you set per-transaction spending limits with virtual and purchase cards?

Yes, both virtual cards and purchase cards allow you to set specific spending limits to control costs. However, they do so in slightly different ways, with virtual cards offering more granular, transaction-specific controls that are ideal for precise maverick spend control.

Setting limits with virtual cards

Virtual cards provide the most precise financial controls available. Because each card can be created for a single purpose, its spending limits can be tailored to an exact transaction, budget, or timeframe. This flexibility makes them a powerful tool for enforcing spending policies automatically.

Key controls include:

• Maximum charge amount: You can set a card to authorize a payment up to a specific dollar amount and decline anything over it. For a one-time software purchase of $299, the card can be set to that exact limit.
• Total budget limit: For recurring payments or ongoing projects, a card can be funded with a total budget that depletes over time (e.g., $1,200 for a year-long subscription at $100/month).
• Virtual card expiration: You can set a card to expire after a specific date or even after a single use. This is perfect for short-term projects or trial subscriptions, as it automatically prevents any future charges.

Setting purchase card per-transaction limits

Purchase cards also offer robust controls, though they are typically applied on a broader, employee-centric level rather than a transaction-specific one. The primary goal of a purchase card per-transaction limit is to keep individual buys below a certain threshold, ensuring the card is used for its intended purpose of managing smaller expenses.

Key controls include:

• Cyclical spending limits: P-cards are typically assigned a total spending limit per month or billing cycle for each cardholder.
• Single-transaction limits: Most P-card programs allow an administrator to set a maximum amount for any single purchase. For example, an employee might have a $2,000 monthly limit but a $500 per-transaction limit to prevent large, unapproved purchases.
• Merchant category code (MCC) restrictions: This powerful feature allows you to block entire categories of spending, such as air travel or restaurants, ensuring the card is only used for approved types of goods and services.

How virtual cards provide superior maverick spend control

Virtual cards offer unparalleled maverick spend control by locking funds to a specific use case. Through a combination of vendor-locking, strict budget caps, and time-based expirations, they ensure company money is spent exactly as intended, leaving no room for out-of-policy purchases.

Vendor-locking for precise payments

The standout feature of a virtual card is the ability to lock it to a single vendor. A vendor-locked virtual card can only be used with the merchant it was assigned to. If someone tries to use that card number for a different vendor, the transaction is automatically declined. This is a game-changer for managing subscriptions and recurring vendor payments automation. For example, a virtual card created for your monthly Adobe Creative Cloud subscription cannot be used for an unapproved purchase on Amazon. This eliminates the risk of both accidental misuse and intentional fraud.

Budget and time-based controls

Beyond vendor-locking, virtual cards enforce strict budget adherence. When you issue a virtual card for a specific purchase—say, $500 for a marketing campaign’s ad spend—that card cannot be charged a penny more. The same applies to time. By setting a virtual card expiration date, you ensure it can’t be used after a project is complete, preventing surprise charges or auto-renewals you forgot to cancel.

Real-time visibility and transaction data

Every transaction made with a virtual card appears instantly in a central dashboard, providing real-time visibility into who is spending what, where, and when. Because each card is tied to a specific purchase or vendor, reconciliation is dramatically simplified. The purpose of the expense is known before the purchase is even made, which streamlines the work for accounting teams and provides a crystal-clear audit trail. This level of insight is crucial for accurate spend analysis.

Ebook

Choose the Right Procurement Technology With This Decision Matrix

Find 15 must-ask questions to narrow down your software search and make your research process MUCH easier.

Download

"*" indicates required fields

Facebook

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

First Name*

Last Name*

Company*

Email*

Phone

Pros and cons of a virtual-first corporate card strategy

A virtual-first card strategy offers significant benefits in security, control, and data tracking, but it may face challenges with in-person purchases and vendor acceptance. Understanding these trade-offs is key to determining if it’s the right approach for your business.

Pros of a virtual-first strategy

• Enhanced security: Since each transaction uses a unique card number, your primary account information is never exposed to vendors. This drastically reduces the risk of payment fraud from external data breaches.
• Granular spend control: Issuing cards for individual purchases, subscriptions, or employees gives you precise control over every dollar spent. This proactive approach to spend management prevents budget overruns before they happen.
• Simplified reconciliation and accounting: Virtual card transactions can be pre-coded with GL codes, departments, and projects. This level of detail automates a large portion of the reconciliation process, saving the finance team hours of manual work.
• Empowered and agile teams: Employees can quickly get approval and a dedicated virtual card to make necessary purchases, eliminating the frustrating delays and security risks of sharing a physical company card.

Cons of a virtual-first strategy

• In-person purchase limitations: Virtual cards are designed for online, card-not-present transactions. They are not ideal for travel expenses, client dinners, or other in-person purchases where a physical card is required.
• Vendor acceptance: While most online vendors accept virtual cards without issue, some smaller or more traditional suppliers may require a physical card or another form of payment.
• Administrative overhead without a platform: Manually creating, tracking, and managing hundreds of individual virtual cards can become a significant administrative burden. The benefits of a virtual-first strategy are best realized through a platform that automates card issuance and management.

Unifying payments with a centralized purchasing platform

The true power of virtual cards is unlocked when they are integrated into a centralized purchasing platform. This approach moves beyond just controlling payments and starts managing the entire procurement lifecycle, from request and approval to reconciliation. It connects the "how" of paying with the "what" and "why" of buying.

From purchase request to automated payment

In an integrated system, the workflow is seamless. An employee needs to make a purchase, so they submit a request through a central platform. The system can automatically generate a virtual card with the exact budget and controls needed for that specific purchase. The transaction data flows back into the platform, closing the loop for effortless reconciliation. This end-to-end automation saves time for everyone involved and creates a perfect audit trail.

Connecting payments to a guided marketplace

The most advanced solution for maverick spend control connects this automated payment workflow to a guided marketplace. A platform like Order.co allows you to create a curated catalog of pre-approved products from preferred vendors. Employees are guided to purchase on-policy items at negotiated prices, eliminating the guesswork and rogue spending that happens when they are left to buy on their own.

How Order.co brings it all together

Order.co unifies every aspect of the buying and payment process into a single, intuitive platform. Instead of just giving you a better way to pay, we give your team a better way to buy.

• Guided buying: Create custom catalogs with your preferred products and vendors, ensuring every purchase is compliant with brand standards and budgets.
• Automated approvals: Set up dynamic approval workflows to route purchase requests to the right people, eliminating bottlenecks and manual follow-ups.
• Seamless payments: Order.co handles all vendor payments on your behalf. Whether the vendor needs a virtual card, ACH, or check, we take care of it. You receive one consolidated invoice for all your purchases, dramatically simplifying reconciliation.
• Full visibility: With all purchasing and payment data in one place, you gain real-time visibility into your organization’s spending, enabling better forecasting and more strategic decision-making.

Choosing the right solution for managing vendor payments

The best solution for managing vendor payments depends on your company’s spending culture and operational needs. For businesses struggling with online subscriptions and a high volume of digital transactions, virtual cards for vendor payments offer unmatched security. For those looking to empower employees with a controlled way to handle small, routine expenses, P-cards are a practical tool.

However, for organizations aiming to fundamentally solve the problem of maverick spend and streamline their entire procurement process, a standalone card solution is not enough. The most effective strategy is to adopt a unified procurement software that integrates guided buying with automated payments. This approach addresses spending at its source—the point of purchase—to ensure every dollar is spent wisely, accountably, and within policy.

By centralizing purchasing and automating the procure-to-pay lifecycle, you move from reactively controlling spend to proactively guiding it. To see how a unified platform can transform your vendor payments and eliminate maverick spend for good, schedule a demo of Order.co.